JOEL KOTKIN
For someone who spent much of the ’90s insisting that Los Angeles was not about to fall into the Pacific without benefit of an earthquake, this past week should have been a gratifying one.
With Los Angeles gaining the Democratic Convention and possibly an NFL franchise in a single week, the phone has been ringing off the hook from a national press that, at last, seems willing to acknowledge our town’s resurrection from the ranks of the dead.
Oddly, this acknowledgement comes not at the inception of L.A.’s recovery, but what may well be its crest. Like medieval theologians, the national media may be coming to the Los Angeles recovery story only as the weight of logic and evidence was simply too overwhelming for them to ignore. The convention and the NFL provide a convenient pretext for writing something that would have seemed fresh three or four years ago.
To be sure, these new developments, as well as the arguably more important signs of change such as Hollywood redevelopment, the DreamWorks move into Playa Vista, the downtown cathedral and the Staples Center indicate that Los Angeles has recovered from its doldrums of the early ’90s.
Less clear is how that forward momentum can be maintained.
A case can be made, in fact, that L.A.’s comeback may already be nearing its denouement. Job growth, although still healthy, has been tilting down, and it now appears that the rate of office, industrial and retail absorption is beginning to slow. The lag between Los Angeles County and the new stars of the state’s economy Orange, the Inland Empire and San Diego has been lengthening.
This is particularly troubling for those parts of the area North Hollywood, South Central Los Angeles, Long Beach, downtown and East Los Angeles late to the recovery table. Unlike hotspots like Burbank, Glendale and the Westside, which may have already absorbed about as much growth as they can reasonably hold, these areas need a continuing robust recovery. Only when prices in the strong areas rise can secondary markets begin to reap the benefits of growth.
Until then, Los Angeles will continue to have a kind of marbleized prosperity, with some strong pockets and too many weak ones.
This pattern of simultaneous hyper and sluggish growth could also have political ramifications. Prosperity tends to strengthen the not-in-my-backyard forces in the more affluent areas, while dulling the instinct for business to push its agenda. Even the good news about the Democrats and the NFL could lure pro-business forces, including some allied with Mayor Richard Riordan, into thinking that they have done all that is needed to recast Los Angeles as a pro-growth city.
Such lassitude would be a mistake at this time. There are signs of weakness appearing within three of the key wealth-creating sectors that drove the ’90s recovery.
One key example has been international trade, which added roughly 100,000 new jobs in the past decade. Last year L.A.’s trade volume dropped for the first time in over 15 years. Continuing problems in East Asia, particularly Japan, as well as growing competition from East Coast ports, could undermine our city’s recent assumption as the nation’s trade leader.
A second area of concern is the garment industry, which is currently undergoing a significant restructuring. Repeatedly written off as anachronistic and exploitative, the industry has survived and even thrived in the face of negative publicity, growing global competition, and occasional labor unrest.
Yet now the lure of cheap production in Mexico appears to be real, with no real growth for the last 18 months. Although the quality of the remaining jobs may continue to improve, the garment industry’s ability to absorb vast numbers of relatively poorly educated immigrants may have passed its prime.
The third critical area lies in the heart of the ’90s Los Angeles recovery: the cultural industrial complex. Like trade, this has been a generator of new jobs, roughly 100,000 this decade, many of them highly paid. Yet employment over the past year appears to have leveled off, even declined slightly, as overall entertainment production drops and some flees for low-cost locales in places like British Columbia, Australia and New Zealand. The period when 10,000 or more new entertainment jobs were added annually appears to have passed for the time being. Several new office projects connected to the industry now appear to be on hold.
So far, weakness in these sectors has been more than made up by recoveries in those areas notably business services and construction that had unraveled most dramatically in the earlier part of this decade. After years of having among the lowest rate of business service growth in the nation, last year Los Angeles experienced a nearly 10 percent expansion, roughly twice that of New York (the media’s favorite comeback city). But continuing erosion in the three wealth-creating sectors, as opposed to tertiary services, will ultimately slow their growth.
In this respect, the city’s business, political and labor leaders need to remain focused not on symbolic victories, but in sustaining those sectors that drove the recovery in the first place.
Having the Democratic Convention here or a football team with an L.A. logo may provide the pretext for a rare spate of positive coverage, but it will do relatively little to create long-term jobs and wealth in the region.
Business Journal columnist Joel Kotkin is a senior fellow with the Pepperdine Institute for Public Policy and a research fellow at the Reason Public Policy Institute.
