To say our city has not had a good year demonstrates my capacity for understatement. From horrific fires that blackened our skies, to riots that blackened our reputation, from chronic budget deficits that embarrass us before the nation, to filth and graffiti that adorn our walls like grotesque tattoos – we live not in the radiant City of Angels, but in a metropolis in measurable decline.
And now, a new symbol flashes in neon red: Playboy, that most quintessentially L.A. brand, is fleeing its ancestral home. Miami Beach, a city that smells opportunity the way a wolf smells blood, will now host Playboy’s headquarters and its approximately 100 staff. As if this were not sufficient humiliation, consider the iconic In-N-Out Burger – born and bred in California – whose leadership decamped to Tennessee.
Ben Kohn, chief executive of Playboy, delivered a verdict more damning than any jury could: “California is anti-business.” His words struck with the blunt force of a bullet in flight.
Is this not confirmation that it is long past time for L.A. leaders to awaken from their civic coma and alter course from an anti-business operating method that bleeds enterprise, jobs and dignity?
The evidence of decline
Academic and economic research makes clear that anti-business policies – excessive taxation, regulatory overreach and bureaucratic hostility – create civic decline. Consider New York City in the 1970s. A study by the National Bureau of Economic Research concluded that punitive taxes and crushing regulatory costs contributed significantly to the exodus of businesses and the city’s near bankruptcy in 1975. It required a federal bailout and draconian fiscal reform to save the Big Apple.
Detroit offers an even starker warning. Wayne State University’s economic historians have documented how regulatory sclerosis and political hostility toward private capital drove auto suppliers and other firms to more hospitable states. The result? The hollowing out of a once-mighty industrial titan.
Harvard Business Review, in a much-cited article, has underscored that “cities hostile to business do not merely lose jobs – they lose ambition, innovation, and civic spirit.” Anti-business leadership, in other words, kills not just companies but cultures.
Los Angeles at a crossroads
What is most tragic about L.A.’s plight is that our civic decline is self-inflicted. We remain blessed with natural beauty, cultural cachet and the magnetic draw of entertainment. But businesses do not operate on sunshine and Instagram likes. They calculate costs, risks and the likelihood of municipal sanity. Increasingly, the arithmetic is grim.
When headquarters like Playboy’s decamp, they do not merely take a logo and a mailing address. They take families, property taxes, charitable contributions and civic pride. They take our children’s future job opportunities and move them 2,700 miles away.
What must be done
Permit me, then, to state bluntly:
1. End the hostility toward business. Our leaders must stop treating entrepreneurs as criminals with better accountants. Regulation should protect health and fairness, not serve as a cudgel.
2. Reform the tax burden. A UCLA study on California’s business climate confirmed what every CFO already knows: high corporate and marginal tax rates accelerate outmigration. L.A. must become competitive again, or risk losing its tax base.
3. Restore order and pride. Graffiti, filth and unchecked crime are not minor inconveniences; they are broken windows that signal a city in surrender. As Wilson and Kelling’s famed “Broken Windows” theory (Atlantic Monthly, 1982) makes clear, disorder tolerated at the margins metastasizes into decline at the core.
A warning
You may be tempted to dismiss the Playboy move as symbolic. But symbols matter. When the bunny hops east, it is not just a magazine or mansion departing – it is the whisper of inevitability. It is a reminder to ambitious companies across the city that they need not endure abuse when friendlier climates await them in Miami, Nashville, Dallas or Phoenix.
Do not delude yourselves: civic greatness is not a birthright. Once lost, it is devilishly hard to recover. New York clawed back in the 1990s under Giuliani, only after two decades of misery. Detroit has not clawed back at all.
A call to courage
Los Angeles does not need more committees, task forces or moral preening. It needs courage. It requires leaders willing to say, in unison: “Enough. This is a city open for business once again.”
Fail to act, and your legacy will not be one of bold stewardship, but of somnolence – leaders who fiddled with slogans while the city that once lit the world burned into irrelevance.
It is past time to awaken.
Michael Levine is a veteran Los Angeles public relations executive who has represented Academy Award and Grammy Award winners. He has written many books including “Broken Windows, Broken Business.”
