Rub your eyes. Gemstar-TV Guide International Inc., a cocky fighter in the media world, was decked this month by investors who sold the stock in a pique over a sketchy earnings report. It was a rare comeuppance for a company that is accustomed to calling the shots.

Gemstar, the largest distributor of interactive-television program guides, owns an arsenal of patents that torments competitors and has given the Pasadena-based company an aura of invincibility.

But Gemstar's stock fell after the company disclosed only its revenue and cash flow in an eight-page press release. The selloff was a rebuke by Wall Street, which expects more guidance from a company with a $20 billion market capitalization and major shareholders such as News Corp. and AT & T;'s Liberty Media Corp. (each with 21 percent).

Gemstar Chairman Henry Yuen defended the initial omission of per-share results because, he said, large write-offs associated with its $14.9 billion purchase of TV Guide Inc. in July would "swamp the type of operating income that we would be able to post."

After the plunge, Gemstar filed a more conventional quarterly report with the Securities and Exchange Commission, reporting a net loss of $115.8 million for the three months ended Sept. 30. The company also took the unusual step of holding a second conference call, to provide more details about its operations.

Gemstar is that odd mixture of a little-known company behind a nearly ubiquitous product: VCR Plus, which enables consumers to program their VCRs by entering four digits on a remote control for devices equipped with its technology.

With the 1997 acquisition of StarSight Telecast Inc., which owned key patents in the interactive program guide business, Gemstar became an aggressive litigant. Among the companies sued by Gemstar for alleged patent infringement: General Instrument Corp., Pioneer Electronic Corp., Scientific-Atlanta Inc., TiVo Inc. and, last month, EchoStar Communications Corp.

When a lawsuit is settled, the terms look advantageous for Gemstar. Last month, Gemstar received $190 million from General Instrument's parent, Motorola Inc., to settle its legal dispute and enter a long-term license agreement for Gemstar's interactive program guide technology.

Gemstar settled a lawsuit against TV Guide, its chief competitor, with its acquisition of the publisher in July. Although the purchase drew opposition, it cleared U.S. Justice Department scrutiny for antitrust problems.

Admiring market clout

"The fact is, a patent is legalized monopoly," said Josh Bernoff, a television analyst with Forrester Research Inc. in Cambridge, Mass.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, CLICK HERE.

Prev